Afra Raymond did a short interview with Dareece Polo of CNC3 Television and Guardian media on the legality of the new exemptions to the Public Procurement & Disposal of Public Property Act. This is an extension to a series of questions arising from the “emergency exemptions” arising from the CARICOM 50th anniversary celebrations in Trinidad and Tobago.
4th July 2023
The Editor,
The Ministry of Trade and Industry (MTI) responded on Sunday, 18 June 2023 to my letter of Friday, 16 June 2023, which pointed-out that the Minister’s reported statement that Trinidad Hilton “had not been renovated for over 20 years” was entirely untrue.
The MTI’s second paragraph confirmed my statements that Trinidad Hilton had been extensively renovated in a program which commenced in 2008. The rest of the MTI’s letter set out some details of the works which are now proposed for that property, but while it is good that we now have that greater level of detail, some serious questions now arise.
My analysis of the Trinidad Hilton, given the estimated profits, as derived from the reported payments of Corporation Tax, shows that the payments of Rent to eTecK would be –
| Year | Net Profit (after tax, consistent with AGOP) | Rent @76% of Net Profit | Return on Investment ($634M) |
| 2015 | $3.099M | $2.355M | 0.37% |
| 2016 | $6.233M | $4.737M | 0.75% |
| 2017 | $2.533M | $1.925M | 0.31% |
| 2018 | $1.987M | $1.510M | 0.24% |
These estimates indicate extremely low rates of Return on Investment, which no private sector investor would tolerate, especially given the ongoing requirement for expensive periodic capital works.
The concerns all relate to the investment decision, given that the State owns the three largest hotels in T&T – Trinidad Hilton, Hyatt Regency and Magdalena Grand in Tobago.
Since the MTI has engaged in this much-needed disclosure, it would be in the public interest if these details could be now provided –
The Department of Management Studies at the Faculty of Social Sciences at UWI St Augustine offers post-graduate studies on Tourism and Management, so it would be interesting to have their input on these large-scale investment decisions.
Finally, what are the Ministry’s responses?
Afra Raymond, former JCC President
The Editor,
The Office of Procurement Regulation (OPR) Chairman’s position has been vacant since 11th January 2023, with no official indication as to when that vacancy is to be filled. The OPR is an important institution which needs capable and experienced leadership, so we need to have that appointment made without any further delay.
I am reliably informed that this important appointment is being actively considered, but we need to ensure that a sound decision is made in the public interest. The inaugural Regulator, Moonilal Lalchan, was appointed in 2018 after the job was advertised by President Carmona in 2017, so the precedent has been set to publicly invite applications for this position. (See advertisement below)
Mr Lalchan performed well, without any complaints or concerns being expressed, so his reappointment ought to be a priority if we are to operationalise this important new Office to defend the Public Interest. In the alternative, the President should activate a transparent process to appoint a suitable candidate without further delay. The Regulator’s post has been vacant since January 2023 and President Kangaloo took office three months ago, so this vacancy now needs to be advertised.
Thank you.
Afra Raymond
former JCC President
afraraymond.net
The Editor,
According to official records, Senator Paula Gopee-Scoon was appointed Minister of Trade & Industry on September 11, 2015, after the current PNM administration took office.
‘Major upgrades to Hilton to start this year‘ was the headline of the extensive article in the Express Business of 14 June 2023 in which Minister Gopee-Scoon was reported to have stated – “… Gopee-Scoon indicated that the hotel was built in 1962 and has not been renovated in over 20 years…”. The Minister’s assertion that Trinidad Hilton had not been renovated in over 20 years is astonishing and entirely untrue. As I reported in this space, previously drawn from the Parliament’s 2016 JSC Report into the operations of eTeck:
…In 2016, the Parliament’s JSC examined the operations of e TecK with particular reference to its accounts and finances. Its Report was published in September 2016 and makes intriguing reading, given the stakes here. According to the President of e Teck, Robert Salandy, in his testimony to the Joint Select Committee on 6 April 2016, the project costs have escalated from an original estimate of $484M to a current figure of $634M. A total of $508M had been spent and it was reported that “…Salandy could not give a time-frame in which the renovations at the Hilton hotel would be completed…”
Property Matters – Trinidad Hilton Improvements
Of course the public cannot tell if this plainly untrue statement emerged as a result of poor-record-keeping, a collapse of Institutional Memory, a genuine error/oversight within the Minister’s office or some other misfortune, but the Ministry of Trade & Industry needs to rectify the record, in the public interest.
Thank you.
Afra Raymond,
former JCC President
Afraraymond.net
Afra Raymond chats with Shabaka Kambon, Dr. Claudius Fergus and Amb. Rev. Kwame Kamau on the Emancipation Support Committee’s online radio programme “INDABA: Where Knowledge Grows” on Talk City 91.1FM on Wednesday, 31 May 2023. They speak on the implementation of the new Public Procurement & Disposal of Public Property Act in Trinidad and Tobago.
The previous article dealt with the sudden unexplained shift from the supposedly-defective Public Procurement & Disposal of Public Property Act (the Act) to the welcome announcement of its proclamation, so long-overdue. I called for an official explanation for this sudden shift, but there has been no response thus far.
The silence of our Learned friends on this issue is as echoing and eerie as it is eloquent. These colleagues have opinions on so much else. Yes, Power is defined by those things you are not allowed to speak about, so self-censorship is as real as the nose on your face. Well I tell you eh!
This article will challenge the basis for the 2020 exemptions to the Act (via Act #27 of 2020), which included Government to Government Agreements (G2G are usually the hugest projects); matters of national security; legal services; debt financing services for the national budget; accounting and auditing services; medical emergency or other scheduled medical services. The Government decided that these transactions in Public Money did not require the oversight of the Office of Procurement Regulation (OPR) which the Parliament approved. I think that inimical to the public interest.
Continue reading “What is the gap in our new Public Procurement law?”“Ambiguity and silence is the enemy of #ethics and #integrity.”
Richard Bistrong @Richardbistrong Twitter feed. Dec 5, 2019
“‘Manufactured consent’ is supported by…effective and powerful ideological institutions that carry out a system-supportive propaganda function by reliance on market forces, internalized assumptions, and self-censorship, and without overt coercion.”
Noam Chomsky, Manufacturing Consent: The Political Economy of the Mass Media 1988, (New York: Pantheon Books)
The Public Procurement & Disposal of Public Property Act (the Act) was fully proclaimed on Wednesday 26 April 2023, which makes that one of our Republic’s truly historic days by any measure.
I welcomed the decision to proclaim the Act, since even with the damaging suite of 2020 exemptions, this is a tremendous step in the right direction of Accountability, Transparency and Good Governance so that we can achieve improved Value for Money in our Public Affairs. The Private Sector Civil Society Group wrote and lobbied for this important law, so this is the result of long-term, collective effort. We owe serious appreciation to those who persisted when this was a faraway vision.
Continue reading “Manufactured Consent in new Public Procurement law?”
Afra Raymond is interviewed on CCN TV6 ‘Morning Edition‘ by host, Lance Mottley on Tuesday, 25 April 2023 on the implementation of the Public Procurement & Disposal of Public Property Act. Video courtesy CCN TV6
Afra Raymond was interviewed on The Power Breakfast Show on Power 102 FM ,radio on Monday, 24 April 2023 with Paul Richards, Richard Ragoobarsingh and Wendell Stephens, on the impending proclamation of the Public Procurement law.
Afra Raymond is CNC3 interviewed on Morning Brew television programme on Monday 24th April 2023 with Jason ‘JW’ Williams on the impending proclamation of the new Public Procurement law. Video courtesy CNC3
AfraRaymond.net 