Property Matters – Sandals MoU? Part three

Sandals/Beaches Tobago Illustrative Master Plan

The previous article delved into the published information on the three existing State-owned hotels and juxtaposed that with the proposals for a Tobago Sandals. Apart from the unsatisfactory position with the State’s existing hotel investments and the reluctance to give details, I also updated readers on the missing MoU for the Tobago Sandals project.

My dismal readings were based on the very limited publicly-available information, nothing else. I did not refer to any rumours or ‘inside information‘, my work is all based on the published record. The PM and his colleagues surely have ready access to a better quality and quantity of information than the public. That being the case, it begs the question as to what is really happening here.

If indeed, the Sandals project has significant upsides and benefits, those ought to have been estimated and shared by now. If the existing State-owned hotels are doing well, why aren’t the management agreements or accounts published? If those hotels are doing poorly, why are we persisting with that same model?

We need a proper examination of those existing hotels so that the Sandals negotiations can take place on the basis of sound information. That is all I am saying.

On 13th June 2018, newly-elected Bajan, PM Mia Mottley QC, made a series of important statements on the issue of public concessions and subsidies in the hotel sector –

“In fact, she told a gathering of industry stakeholders…that what it had essentially done was to create three classes of hoteliers in the country.

“Those like Sandals that get everything without consultation, . . . those who have to come to the Ministry of Tourism…which is nonsense, and then those who don’t even get anywhere near the Ministry of Tourism…and as a result therefore they are precluded from being a beneficiary of any of those concessions,”…

However, while warning that it “cannot be the way”, the Prime Minister said to loud applause that “one of the early things the Ministry of Tourism will be looking at is how to bring about greater equity as well as fairness and transparency in the management of those concessions under the Tourism Development Act…”

Sandals responded with a four-page Press Release which was widely covered in the media and focused on the benefits which Sandals had brought to its Caribbean destinations. As always, my focus is on the decisive factor of the ‘underlying commercial arrangements‘ which are the real drivers of these large-scale, long-term developments.

My response to the Office of the Prime Minister is here –

Advertisements

5 thoughts on “Property Matters – Sandals MoU? Part three

  1. Dear Afra… Again thanks for staying the course. You are indeed a worthy “Guardian of the Guards”. I have been missing your forensic and determined work on the Sandals project. Will catch up. My interest here however continues to be that we in T&T cannot get our act together to satisfy ALL concerned. Can’t understand the need for all this ‘cloak and dagger’ dealings that only throw suspicion on any business matter. What is it to be learnt from the other Sandal Sister Islands that can enable us to proceed? For certainly since we cannot do it ourselves – move our Tourism forward that is – the sooner we must get a little help from The Professionals. And Butch Stewart certainly has proven himself!
    RhonaB.

  2. Property Matters – Sandals MoU? Part Three
    There seems to be an eternal blindness to the global expropriation of wealth by a few through any means possible. This mercurial process is simultaneously and consciously tangible and intangible. Today’s yes is equal to tomorrow’s no. George Orwell conceptualised it in his book titled 1984 and Fanon explained both its physical and psychological realities and projections in his book called The Wretched of the Earth.
    In Trinidad and Tobago, critical reading is anathema and even those who do are often led into a despair that translates into non-action. We have abundant proof that our puppet leaders have little choices and fewer spines but the rewards for them transform morals into survival. Teaching probity is casting pearls before the blind and a dis-service to our young who shall inherit this mess.
    As always with every rising sun, there is hope that these matters add to the pure drops that fall into our oceans of corruption and create a stratum of dignity that will unearth the goodwill our religions promise. If we accept Chief Secretary, Kelvin Charles’ assurances of Sandals’ numerous benefits, then whatever is written or spoken will be masked by those publicised half-truths. While Afra seeks the whole loaf, many yearn for fallen crumbs. Self-constricted minds are as impermeable as granite to water.

  3. The claim that tourism is a career is the same as our belief that foreign aid will alleviate poverty. Both myths still predominate as truisms in and out of the media. The word, independence, should direct our learnings.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.