Property Matters – State Offices – part 2

Noel Garcia, former MD of HDC. Photo courtesy Trinidad Guardian
Noel Garcia, UDeCOTT chairman. Photo courtesy Trinidad Guardian

On 5 January 2016 the Business page of the Trinidad Express newspaper carried an article titled ‘Millions to be saved from rent‘ in which the UDeCOTT Chairman, Noel Garcia, advised on the progress in completing the State-owned offices in Port of Spain. That was also the topic of last week’s Property Matters column, so this week I will be trying to reconcile the two sets of information and make some further points.

The program for completion of these offices, as announced on 18 July 2014 by then Minister of Housing and Urban Development, Dr Roodal Moonilal, was to have had them all occupied by the end of 2015, with some substantial completions due at a far earlier date. Garcia stated that the last of these buildings would be ready for occupation in June and also that ‘all works with respect to the project were on schedule‘. Obviously there was significant slippage in the projected completion of this huge series of offices, originally described by Moonilal as ‘an unprecedented feat in the Caribbean‘.

NEW STATE OFFICES IN POS

BUILDING/LOCATION SIZE
(sq.  ft.)
Scheduled Completions
Dr Roodal Moonilal (2014)
2016 PROGRAM
Noel Garcia (2016)
 Customs & Excise HQ, Richmond St. 189,000 October 18th 2014 April 2015
 Board of Inland Revenue, Richmond St. 374,000 August 28th 2015 June 2016
 Ministry of Legal Affairs, Richmond St. 332,000 August 31st 2015 February 2016
 Immigration Division, Richmond St (Formerly Ministry of Social Development) 160,000 March 20th 2015 Completed
 Ministry of Education, St Vincent St. 274,000 No date given March 2016

Sidebar: NIB HQ at Queen’s Park East

NIB-headquartersThe previous column excluded the NIB’s Headquarters which started in December 2014, with completion said to be due in 20 months, which would be in August 2016. That is said to be a mixed-use development which includes an unknown quantity of offices and some retail elements. Please note that NIB is not a State-owned Enterprise or Agency.

The new twin towers at the International Waterfront Centre are now in use, but it is still unclear whether those offices are fully occupied.

Out-turn costs

This mammoth project actually started 11 years ago, so the delay has been considerable. Even more considerable has been the costs of the entire exercise, both the direct and indirect ones.

The society has been made to pay an immense amount of money in relation to the Government Campus Plaza, as the entire project was called.

It is very important, in my view, that there be a detailed and public accounting of how these vast sums of Public Money have been spent. That is called the out-turn cost and must include these items –

  • Professional fees paid to Architects, Engineers, Project Managers, Interior Designers and Surveyors;
  • Monies paid under the terms of original Building Contracts to include original contract sums and further amounts paid due to variations, fluctuations or renegotiations;
  • Monies paid under the terms of ‘fitting-out’ Contracts to include original contract sums and further amounts paid due to variations, fluctuations or renegotiations;
  • Payments to Utility Companies

A further item beyond out-turn costs, which almost never forms part of these discussions, is the value of the land occupied by the buildings, which was already the subject of manipulation in relation to this ambitious UDECOTT program. I am referring to the fact that the 2006 audited accounts for UDECOTT disclosed a value of $224M for the site of the International Waterfront Project, yet that land value was omitted from the ‘feasibility test’ for that project. That is according to the sworn testimony of then UDECOTT Executive Chairman, Calder Hart, at the Uff Enquiry.

Collateral Costs

Time is Money‘ is an age-old saying intended to convey the silent therefore often-unnoticed costs of delay in business.

In the first place, private interests were disturbed by the State’s massive intervention in ‘crowding-out’ private landlords by means of this huge office-building exercise. There is no doubt in my mind that the occupation of these State-owned offices in POS will have a severely detrimental effect on those property owners who have traditionally rented offices to the State. That debate could be seen as largely academic, since the buildings have now all been built. It is still very important for us to understand the true costs and consequences of proceeding in this way.

That leads us directly to the second cost of the delays on the part of the State in occupying these offices, which is the huge amounts of rent paid to private landlords in the years since this ambitious complex was completed, but not ready for occupation. Of course, the very phrase ‘completed, but not ready for occupation‘ is a pregnant one, but there is meaning in the paradox.

According to then Minister of Finance & the Economy, Larry Howai, on 5 May 2014 –  “Cabinet has approved a sum of approximately $1.5 billion to complete the Government Campus buildings in downtown Port-of-Spain,”. The cost of outfitting these offices was then declared to be $1.5Bn and that program was commenced about four years into the Peoples Partnership’s five-year term in office. One can never be certain what was the cause of this delay, but it seems reasonable to conclude that the PP’s priorities lay elsewhere, at least in terms of their physical development program.

In the previous column, I suggested that $8 per square foot was a modest estimate of the average rental cost of the private offices occupied by the State in the period under examination. If we assume that 1.3M square feet of private offices was occupied by the State that equates to an annual rental bill of $125M. Given that the last of these buildings was ‘completed, but not ready for occupation’ in 2010, it means that one can estimate that an additional $625M was paid to private landlords in the five years before the fitting-out was completed.

Those are modest estimates and we can only know the truth of this issue when the actual rents are published, as part of our essential interest in understanding the business of our Republic. I know for certain that there were substantial rentals in excess of the $8psf average stated, so that is an essential set of facts we need to have published.

Sidebar: Newly-vacated State property

This series of shifts in State occupation has now released certain properties for alternative uses –

  • Ministries of Agriculture, Land & Fisheries – This is a prime property at the northern end of the ‘Magnificent Seven’ stretch of Queen’s Park West/Maraval Road. It is said to be carded for a hotel project so that proposal must be carefully scrutinised.
  • Ministry of Education – This is a substantial prime property on Alexandra Street, between St. Clair Avenue and Hayes Street.
  • Government Printery – This property is on Tragarete Road at the corner of Victoria Avenue and became unoccupied when the Government Printery was relocated to Frederick Settlement in Caroni in March 2014.

The redevelopment of these newly-vacant State-owned properties will be challenging in commercial terms, due in significant part to the creation of these brand-new first class offices and the impact of those on the wider market.

The vacated offices

Now that these long-delayed offices are nearing completion, we also need to insist on the prompt termination of leases/tenancy agreements with private landlords.

At this point, we simply cannot afford another ‘One Alexandra Place’ situation in which this large privately-owned office building at the corner of Tragarete Road and Alexandra Street was rented by the State for five years but never occupied. The monthly rent for that property was disclosed to be of the order of $60o,000, which means that over $35M of Public Money was wasted there. That episode needs to be properly explained so that we can avoid a recurrence.

Are we still paying rent for any empty spaces?

Advertisements

6 thoughts on “Property Matters – State Offices – part 2

  1. Dear Afra…Thanks for your continuing good work on exposing the nitty gritty of Big Business… OUR Business.From afar, I seem to have a better perspective on the country from this wintry retreat we have chosen … viz a return to China. There is no better time nor place… One wonders why things take so long for action… and one wonders whether it is not the democratic process that lends itself to procrastination and the attendant corruption etc… fueled by greed. Democracy is a convenient scapegoat for inaction. How to get around this without being accused of Dictatorship? And yet… don’t we vote in people to RUN THE COUNTRY? You refer to the Landlords who will feel the pinch and one wonders why we dither over them when  they have already charged the country as with One Alexandria Place with advantageous rents? And so the conversation should really be about EFFICIENCY and that should begin with IMMEDIATE OCCUPANCY into new quarters with PAYMENTS TO ARCHITECTS etc following on its heels… rather than the other way around.RhonaB…and thanks again.

  2. Property Matters – State Offices- part 2
    13th January 2016

    I feel sure that legislation exists to demand accountability for the use (wastage) of public funds. The unbridled fit of international monetary scandals reported in the Ethical Alliance digest, an anti-corruption e-community (ethiXbase) and others demonstrate the crass expansion of unprincipled extortion and abuse of power through multi-national corporations and state agencies. Exposure, fines and court injunctions seem to inflame rather than quench the desire to brazenly defy legal and moral conventions and each elected administration in T&T seems to be desperate to out-do its predecessor. If we listen to their words, replicated via links in Afra’s expose, they manifest the best of intentions but by 2020 our depleted treasury, international debt and escalated unemployment, among other ills, will prompt yet another change for our betterment.

    I wonder: Will we ever discover the true quantities of money paid as rent to landlords who no longer need those sums? Will they ever be named? Will we ever find peace? Will our education, health and other sectors become institutions of great national pride? Crazy says, “In time to come.” Sparrow says, “We like it so.” Rudder says that it’s a mad man’s rant and Chalkdust has been in town too long. Age brings scepticism and fortunately forgetfulness. Religions teach us to suffer now gratefully, for a sanctuary awaits our humility, patience and passivity. Since there is no room for intelligence….

  3. And now we,the ordinary citizens have to suffer and pay what we do not even have for this criminal activity – rampant squandermania.

  4. This issue of property rental by the state has been with us for a long time. I really don’t care about the consequences faced by those who have been doing this for decades, now that the state has finally built its own accommodations. Those private persons have benefited at the expense of others for far too long. Rents paid over the decades could have done so much for the entire country rather than an elite few who own way too much real estate anyways.

    And then there is that issue of the real costs of these projects. which are intended to save the state some money. and the debates continues along with thee cycle.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s